Interpreting and Valuing Christian Opinions on God’s Existence

Introduction

The question of whether Christians are irrational, illogical, and deluded has often sparked debates. Can we seriously consider their opinion that God exists, or should we dismiss it outright?

Jesus himself addressed this very issue, offering profound insights that can help us navigate these discussions with greater discernment.

Christianity and Rationality

Mat. 7:6 and Mat. 10:14

These verses from the Gospel of Matthew contain striking imagery: “Do not give dogs what is sacred do not throw your pearls to pigs. If you do they may trample them under their feet and turn and tear you to pieces.” Similarly, Jesus advises not to engage those who refuse to hear your words: “If anyone will not welcome you or listen to your words leave that home or town and shake the dust off your feet.”

These teachings do not discourage respectful engagement. Instead, they caution against wasting time and energy on those who seek only to criticize and ridicule. This principle applies to anyone, not just Christians.

Unbelievers and Their Opinions

Those who reject Christianity often base their arguments on subjective opinions rather than objective truths. Christians, on the other hand, seek a faith grounded in truth and revelation.

Isa. 45:21-22

The psalmist captures the essence of true faith: “Woe to him who quarrels with his Maker— the potsherd in the hands of the potter! Does the clay say to the potter, ?What are you making? It will not have fingers or toes, so why are you making it? ’” Christians believe that questioning God’s sovereignty is akin to a clay pot complaining about its maker.

Even if a person is convinced of their own righteousness, they must recognize that external validation is essential. A purely internal sense of righteousness lacks the foundation needed to truly impact others.

Engagement and Respect

Acts 17:16-17

In the Book of Acts, we see Paul engaging with the intellectuals of Athens: “Now while Paul was waiting for them in Athens, his spirit was uneasy because he saw that the city was full of idols. So he reasoned in the synagogue with the Jews and with the God-fearing pagans, and every day he debated in the market place with those who met there.”

Paul’s approach was marked by respectful engagement, reason, and an open stance. His goal was to share the truth without being condescending or dismissive. Christians can learn from this example and strive to approach dialogue with honesty and respect.

Critical Reflection and Personal Growth

Asking how an individual is irrational, illogical, or deluded can be a starting point for a constructive conversation. Understanding the reasoning behind someone's beliefs can lead to deeper insights and personal growth.

It's important for Christians to study the Bible not just for rote reading, but for true understanding and application. Teaching the Bible and witnessing must be done with knowledge and respect, showing oneself approved by God.

Conclusion

Whether Christians are perceived as rational, irrational, or somewhere in between, their opinions deserve careful consideration. By engaging with respect, reason, and a commitment to truth, we can foster meaningful conversations and promote a deeper understanding of faith and belief.